פורום ארץ הצבי Enter the forum
Articles
Discussions
About FAZ
FAZ people
columns
Links
Previous page
Bulletine Board

SearchFeedbackAdd to Favorites
RSS Feed
מה זה?
Response.
Avi Goldreich (יום ראשון, 06/07/2008 שעה 18:43) הדפס תגובה/פתילקישור ישיר לתגובה זו

As I have not any acces to hebrew writing computers and it is not so easy to use eurppean one, my response will come in the next stay in Israel.

and it should be in another article David.

_new_ הוספת תגובה



בבקשה ובברכה
דוד סיון (יום ראשון, 06/07/2008 שעה 19:56)
בתשובה לAvi Goldreich
הדפס תגובה/פתילקישור ישיר לתגובה זו

מדוע אינך מנסה להשתמש במקלדת של יובל?
_new_ הוספת תגובה



Yoss'l  (יום ראשון, 06/07/2008 שעה 20:08)
בתשובה לAvi Goldreich
הדפס תגובה/פתילקישור ישיר לתגובה זו

And while you're at it, why don't you look for more books to 'prove' that the Palestinians never existed. Perhaps such newly discovered books will also help justify the massive theft of Palestinian land by Israel over the past forty years. And perhaps you will find one particular book to help you justify your personal contribution to the building of settlements, and the roads leading to them, in the West Bank

I must admit that I truly enjoyed reading the truth about Reland's book, since it was touted by you as a scientific proof of sorts for your racist anti-Palestinian agenda. Poor Reland - he must be turning in his grave, seeing how some overzealous Jews are trying to use his book for their dark purposes, subverting the meaning of his text. And have you come across some other priceless information proving your 'theories', or have you had some more 'anti-semitic' encounters with Germans perhaps

The world is your oyster, Avi Goldreich, and you seem to be traveling it seeking proof of catastrophes long gone - seeking proof that your enemies have no right to exist and that the world hates you because you are a Jew. Good luck with that 
_new_ הוספת תגובה



Wait a litle , and meanwhile
Avi Goldreich (יום שני, 07/07/2008 שעה 5:43)
בתשובה לYoss'l 
הדפס תגובה/פתילקישור ישיר לתגובה זו

give me one book or even one proof that the ''palestinian nation'' existed as a nation .
In the Period of Riland.
Good luck with that.
_new_ הוספת תגובה



We don't have to wait
Yoss'l  (יום שני, 07/07/2008 שעה 6:31)
בתשובה לAvi Goldreich
הדפס תגובה/פתילקישור ישיר לתגובה זו

The proof is already in

Avi Goldreich completely misrepresented
the significance of Reland's book
in order to prove that

''הספר סותר לחלוטין תיאוריות פוסט-מודרניסטיות על ''מורשת פלסטינית'' או עם פלסטיני, ומאשש ומחזק את השייכות של ארץ ישראל ליהודים ואת חוסר שייכותה המוחלט לערבים, ששדדו אפילו את השם הלטיני פלסטינה וניכסו אותו לעצמם''

We are no longer talking about the book itself, or about the
question Goldreich had been obsessed with, and not in a good way.
The subject of our attention has now become the integrity of Avi Goldreich himself, as the one having made the above claim

And there is no turning the tables on me or others who have witnessed the shameful charade perpetrated by Goldereich.
The lights are now turned on Goldreich, but he refuses to take any
responsibility for his actions.

God help to protect us from false prophets, or just from overzealous amateurs, the likes of Goldreich. And a word of advice to Avi Goldreich: when you are caught in a misrepresentation or a lie, the best policy is to admit that you were wrong. Holding on to the scam, only makes things worse.
 
_new_ הוספת תגובה




חזרה לפורוםהסיפור המלא
מערכת פורום ארץ הצבי אינה אחראית לתוכן תגובות שנכתבו בידי קוראים.



© פורום ארץ הצבי